At The Mercy Of The Courts

In 2014, Elvis was working at the internet cafe he owned in a small town outside Guatemala City, when he noticed a girl who kept coming around to print out homework assignments. Her name was Wendy. They started flirting, then started dating, and eventually got married. They settled into a quiet, happy routine.

Less than a year into their marriage, their lives were interrupted when Wendy’s mother received an extortion call. The caller was from one of the largest gangs in Central America, and he demanded close to $2,600. If the family didn’t pay, the caller threatened to kill Wendy and her younger brother.

This was the first in a series of threats that would lead Wendy and Elvis to seek asylum in the United States in early 2019. In the process of seeking safety, they would find themselves navigating a complicated and maddening immigration court system—that has become the norm under the Trump Administration.

Illustration by Alex Charner for Latino USA.

On this episode of Latino USA, we partner with Documented, a nonprofit news site that covers immigrants in New York City, to go behind the scenes into the courtrooms of the U.S. immigration system under Trump.

In 2019, Documented set out to report on the impact of a slew of recent policy changes and Department of Justice rulings on the courts system. Six reporters took turns observing New York’s immigration courts from morning until close, five days a week, for three months.

Over that period, the reporters sat in on more than 200 hearings and witnessed a system that was clearly overwhelmed. Judges were rushed, the court’s scheduling system was rife with errors, and videoconferencing technology would often malfunction. Federal policy changes also made it harder for judges to make decisions on a humanitarian basis.

Elvis at a friend’s home in Guatemala. (Photo by Santiago Billy for Documented/Latino USA)

These problems would have serious real-world impacts on immigrants and their cases. During one hearing, an ICE prosecutor announced they had lost a woman’s file, forcing her to start her case again. In another, a judge apologized to a man who’d been kept in detention for an extra month because the court had sent correspondence saying he was free to leave detention on bond to the wrong address.

By the time Latino USA and Documented met Wendy and Elvis in the winter of 2019, Elvis had been in immigration detention for almost a year and had slowly watched the asylum process tear his family apart. Through court recordings, extortion audio, and other records of their family’s life, an intimate picture emerges of the toll it takes for immigrants, after fleeing violence or threats, to navigate an asylum system increasingly stacked against them.

Maria Hinojosa sat down with co-founders of Documented, Max Siegelbaum and Mazin Sidahmed, to talk about what they observed in New York’s immigration courts, and how federal policy changes have impacted the people moving through them.

Read more about Documented’s reporting in the courts here.

6 thoughts on “At The Mercy Of The Courts

  1. Mexicans are not immigrating to the US. They always have been around, specially in south western States. Florida, Nevada, Texas, Colorado, California, New Mexico, Arizona… All Spanish names, with mexican heritage on them. Good Luck cutting the roots of a tree planted long time before the US even existed as a country.

  2. This is the frequent and sullen response of Mexicans who can’t accept history and their own loss of land. Besides, Mexicans were habitually uninterested in settling in these lands; a few, maybe, but not in numbers. Did North Americans take land? You bet they did, and they weren’t the only people who wanted it: French, Spanish, and others did, also. The only difference is, the Americans won and the Mexicans and others didn’t. Mexico and America are now partly separated by a natural demarcation. When I look at that country — the corruption (their leaders regularly sell them out), the violence, drugs, and lack of respect for the law — there’s no way to believe they deserved those lost areas mentioned by the above writer. They were saved from being a part of a corrupt country and society. And yes, Mexicans are not immigrating to the U.S.: they are invading as illegal aliens and should be turned around to fix their own country and society and not burden ours. By definition an “immigrant” is in this country legally; not so others, who use the terms “asylum” and “refugee” very loosely. Fortunately, Americans are beginning to see through the scam.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Produced by Alissa Escarce, Max Siegelbaum and Mazin Sidahmed. Edited by Sophia Paliza-Carre

This story was reported in partnership with Type Investigations’ Wayne Barrett Project. Ralph Ortega, Phoebe Taylor-Vuolo, Hannah Beckler, Irene Spezzamonte, Grace Moon and Irene Tang contributed reporting.

Illustration by Alex Charner. Photos by Santiago Billy for Documented/Latino USA.